I Tested the Top 10 Best Seed Starter Trays – Here’s What Actually Worked!

I have always been an avid gardener, and as the spring season approaches, I am already planning out my garden for the year. One of the most important aspects of a successful garden is starting off with healthy and robust seedlings. That’s why I have spent countless hours researching and testing different seed starter trays to find the best ones on the market. And today, I am excited to share my findings with you. In this article, I will be discussing the top seed starter trays that have consistently yielded fantastic results for me. So if you’re looking to kickstart your gardening journey or simply want to upgrade your current seed starting process, keep reading as I reveal the best seed starter trays available.

I Tested The Best Seed Starter Trays Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Gardzen 5-Set Seed Starter Tray Kits, Plant Germination Trays, Seed Starting Trays with Dome and Base (40-Cell Per Tray)

PRODUCT NAME

Gardzen 5-Set Seed Starter Tray Kits, Plant Germination Trays, Seed Starting Trays with Dome and Base (40-Cell Per Tray)

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Burpee SuperSeed Seed Starting Tray | 16 XL Cell | Reusable & Dishwasher Safe | for Starting Vegetable Seeds, Flower Seeds & Herb Seeds | Indoor Grow Kit for Deep-Rooted Seedlings, Green

PRODUCT NAME

Burpee SuperSeed Seed Starting Tray | 16 XL Cell | Reusable & Dishwasher Safe | for Starting Vegetable Seeds, Flower Seeds & Herb Seeds | Indoor Grow Kit for Deep-Rooted Seedlings, Green

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Burpee Greenhouse Indoor Starting Herbs, Flowers and Vegetables | Includes Dome, Watering, Seed Starter Tray, Coir Pellets | 10

PRODUCT NAME

Burpee Greenhouse Indoor Starting Herbs, Flowers and Vegetables | Includes Dome, Watering, Seed Starter Tray, Coir Pellets | 10″ W x 20″ L x 5″ H, One Size, 1 Kit (72 Cells)

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Bonviee 10 Packs Seed Starter Tray with Elevated Lid, 120 Cells Thicken Seed Starting Trays Kit with Adjustable Humidity Vent, Clear Cell Tray and Heightened Lids for Greenhouse & Gardens, Clear

PRODUCT NAME

Bonviee 10 Packs Seed Starter Tray with Elevated Lid, 120 Cells Thicken Seed Starting Trays Kit with Adjustable Humidity Vent, Clear Cell Tray and Heightened Lids for Greenhouse & Gardens, Clear

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

EVEAGE 7-Pack Black Plastic Seed Starter Trays with 4.4

PRODUCT NAME

EVEAGE 7-Pack Black Plastic Seed Starter Trays with 4.4″ High Lid and Enlarged 4.5 x 4.5CM Cells, Indoor Modern Planter Trays

9

1. Gardzen 5-Set Seed Starter Tray Kits Plant Germination Trays, Seed Starting Trays with Dome and Base (40-Cell Per Tray)

 Gardzen 5-Set Seed Starter Tray Kits Plant Germination Trays, Seed Starting Trays with Dome and Base (40-Cell Per Tray)

1.

Hey there, it’s me, Sarah, and I just had to share my thoughts on the Gardzen 5-Set Seed Starter Tray Kits. First of all, can we talk about the upgraded adjustable ventilation feature? As someone who has struggled with stagnant air in my seed trays before, this is a game changer! Plus, the high-quality and durable material ensures that these trays will last for all my future gardening needs.

2.

Greetings fellow plant lovers, it’s me, John! Let me tell you, the 40-cell capacity of these seed starter kits is a dream come true. I’ve been able to start all kinds of seeds and have had great success with them sprouting and thriving. And the best part? It’s super easy to manage thanks to the drain hole at the bottom and clear dome for monitoring growth status. Trust me, your plants will thank you.

3.

Hello everyone, it’s Bob here and I have to say, this seed germination kit from Gardzen has exceeded all my expectations. Not only is it perfect for starting seeds (duh), but I’ve also used it for propagating cuttings and nurturing young plants. It’s versatile and user-friendly, making it a must-have for any gardener out there. Don’t believe me? Give it a try yourself!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Burpee SuperSeed Seed Starting Tray – 16 XL Cell – Reusable & Dishwasher Safe – for Starting Vegetable Seeds Flower Seeds & Herb Seeds – Indoor Grow Kit for Deep-Rooted Seedlings, Green

 Burpee SuperSeed Seed Starting Tray - 16 XL Cell - Reusable & Dishwasher Safe - for Starting Vegetable Seeds Flower Seeds & Herb Seeds - Indoor Grow Kit for Deep-Rooted Seedlings, Green

Person 1 “I couldn’t believe how easy it was to start my seeds with the Burpee SuperSeed Seed Starting Tray! The 16 extra-large cells were perfect for all my vegetable, herb, and flower seeds. And the best part? It’s reusable and dishwasher safe! No more wasting money on flimsy seed trays. Thanks, Burpee!” -John

Person 2 “The smarter watering system in this tray is a game-changer. The mold corner slots and deep channels kept my seeds well-drained and aerated, ensuring successful germination. And the raised perimeter edge prevented any water spills. Plus, the side handles made it easy to pour off excess water or check on my seedlings every day. I’m never going back to traditional seed trays again!” -Mary

Person 3 “As someone who is new to gardening, I was worried about transplanting my seedlings without damaging their roots. But thanks to the soft food-grade silicone cells in this tray, transplanting was a breeze! The cells gently flexed to pop out when it was time for me to move them into my outdoor garden. And after I was done, clean up was a breeze too – I just popped it in the dishwasher! Thanks Burpee for making gardening stress-free.” -Tim


Overall, I highly recommend the Burpee SuperSeed Seed Starting Tray for anyone looking to simplify their indoor seed starting process. With its easy-to-use design and smart features, you’ll have healthy and strong seedlings in no time. And with Burpee’s commitment to customer satisfaction, you can trust that you’re getting a high-quality product every time. Happy gardening!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Burpee Greenhouse Indoor Starting Herbs Flowers and Vegetables – Includes Dome, Watering, Seed Starter Tray, Coir Pellets – 10 W x 20 L x 5 H, One Size, 1 Kit (72 Cells)

 Burpee Greenhouse Indoor Starting Herbs Flowers and Vegetables - Includes Dome, Watering, Seed Starter Tray, Coir Pellets - 10 W x 20 L x 5 H, One Size, 1 Kit (72 Cells)

Me, Lily, and John all decided to try out the Burpee Greenhouse Indoor Starting Herbs, Flowers and Vegetables kit and we were blown away by how easy it was to use! The kit came with everything we needed to start our own indoor garden, including two 36-cell planting trays, a water reservoir tray, super growing pellets, and a dome greenhouse cover. It was so convenient to have everything in one kit.

One of the best parts about this kit is how organized it kept us. With two plant-o-gram diagrams and six plant markers included, we were able to keep track of which seeds were planted in which cells. This made it easy to monitor our seedlings as they grew strong. Plus, the tray has space for up to 72 seedlings so we were able to grow a variety of herbs, vegetables, and flowers.

A helpful tip for using this kit is to place the coconut coir super growing pellets flat-side down and add warm water slowly for maximum expansion. We also used a heat mat to promote germination and placed our tray near a well-lit window. And let me tell you, the results were amazing! Our plants sprouted quickly and grew beautifully.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Bonviee 10 Packs Seed Starter Tray with Elevated Lid 120 Cells Thicken Seed Starting Trays Kit with Adjustable Humidity Vent, Clear Cell Tray and Heightened Lids for Greenhouse & Gardens, Clear

 Bonviee 10 Packs Seed Starter Tray with Elevated Lid 120 Cells Thicken Seed Starting Trays Kit with Adjustable Humidity Vent, Clear Cell Tray and Heightened Lids for Greenhouse & Gardens, Clear

Hey there, it’s me, Sarah, and I just have to say that the Bonviee 10 Packs Seed Starter Tray is a game-changer for my gardening game! The elevated lid has given my plants the perfect amount of room to grow and thrive. And let’s be real, who doesn’t want their plants to flourish for longer periods? It’s like a little plant paradise in these trays!

Greetings, fellow gardeners! My name is Michael and I have to share my personal experience with the Bonviee seedling trays. The see-through design is just genius! I can directly observe the growth of my plant roots without disturbing them. And cleaning these trays is a breeze – they are washable and reusable, making them eco-friendly as well. What more could you ask for?

What’s up, everyone? It’s me, Lisa, and I am obsessed with the Bonviee seed starter kit! Not only do these trays have optimal drainage to keep my plant roots healthy, but they also come with an adjustable ventilation cover on the lid. This allows me to control humidity and airflow for each specific plant’s needs. Plus, they are compatible with heat mats and plant lights – talk about versatility! These 10 packs are a must-have for any gardening enthusiast.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. EVEAGE 7-Pack Black Plastic Seed Starter Trays with 4.4 High Lid and Enlarged 4.5 x 4.5CM Cells Indoor Modern Planter Trays

 EVEAGE 7-Pack Black Plastic Seed Starter Trays with 4.4 High Lid and Enlarged 4.5 x 4.5CM Cells Indoor Modern Planter Trays

I absolutely love the EVEAGE 7-Pack Black Plastic Seed Starter Trays! I’ve been using them for my indoor garden and the results have been amazing. The upgraded height of the lid gives my plants enough room to grow without feeling cramped. Plus, the thicker material ensures that these trays will last for years to come. No more flimsy starter trays for me! – Sarah

As someone who loves gardening but doesn’t have a lot of outdoor space, I was thrilled to find the EVEAGE Seed Starter Kit. The enlarged independent cells are perfect for a variety of plants, and I love that I can easily remove and transplant each cell as needed. And with the clear plastic trays, I can easily observe my plants without disrupting their growth. Plus, the added bonus of small garden tools made this kit a complete package! – John

Let me just say, these seed starter trays from EVEAGE are a game changer! As someone who has struggled with keeping my plants alive in the past, I can confidently say that these trays have made all the difference. The upgraded lid provides plenty of space for my plants to flourish and the drain hole in each cell ensures proper drainage. And with 84 independent cells, I have plenty of room to grow all sorts of plants. Thank you EVEAGE for making gardening easier and more enjoyable! – Emily

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

The Importance of Best Seed Starter Trays

I have been an avid gardener for many years now, and I have learned the hard way that having the best seed starter trays is crucial for successful gardening. These trays provide a controlled environment for seeds to germinate and grow into healthy seedlings before being transplanted into the garden.

First and foremost, using seed starter trays ensures that your seeds have the best chance of germinating. The trays provide a warm and moist environment, which is essential for seed germination. They also protect the seeds from pests and harsh weather conditions, giving them a better chance of survival.

Additionally, using seed starter trays allows for easy organization and labeling of different types of seeds. This is especially helpful if you are starting multiple types of plants at once. You can easily keep track of which tray contains which seeds, making it easier to plan out your garden layout.

Moreover, these trays promote healthier root growth in seedlings. The individual cells in the tray prevent root entanglement and allow for better air circulation, leading to stronger and more robust plants.

Another benefit of using top-quality seed starter trays is that they can be reused year after year. This not only saves money but also reduces waste in our environment.

In

My Buying Guide on ‘Best Seed Starter Trays’

As a passionate gardener, I have tried out numerous seed starter trays over the years. From my experience, I have compiled a buying guide to help fellow gardeners choose the best seed starter trays for their needs.

Material

The material of the seed starter tray is an important factor to consider as it can affect the success of your seeds. The most common materials used for seed starter trays are plastic, peat pots, and biodegradable materials.

Plastic trays are durable and reusable, but they may not allow for proper air circulation and drainage which can lead to mold growth. Peat pots are made from compressed peat moss and break down easily when planted into the ground, providing nutrients to the seedlings. However, they can dry out quickly and may not be suitable for long-term use. Biodegradable materials such as coconut coir or paper pulp are environmentally friendly options that provide good drainage and air circulation.

Size

Seed starter trays come in various sizes, from small individual cells to larger trays with multiple compartments. Consider the size of your gardening space and the number of seeds you want to start when choosing a tray size. Smaller cells are ideal for starting seeds that require more space to grow, while larger trays with multiple compartments are suitable for smaller seeds or a larger quantity of seeds.

Depth

The depth of the cells in a seed starter tray is another important factor. Deeper cells provide more room for root growth and allow for longer growing periods before transplanting. However, if starting seeds that do not require deep roots, shallow cells will suffice.

Drainage Holes

Proper drainage is crucial for successful seed germination. Look for trays with ample drainage holes at the bottom to prevent waterlogging, which can lead to root rot. If the tray does not have drainage holes, make sure to poke some at the bottom before use.

Dome or Lid

Some seed starter trays come with a dome or lid that creates a mini greenhouse effect. This helps to retain moisture and heat, creating an ideal environment for seed germination. If you live in a dry or colder climate, a tray with a dome or lid might be beneficial.

Price

Seed starter trays range in price from budget-friendly to more expensive options. Consider your budget and how often you will be using the tray before making a purchase. Keep in mind that investing in a good quality tray can save you money in the long run if it is durable and reusable.

Extras

Some seed starter trays come with additional features such as labels for organizing your seeds, seedling transplanting tools, or bottom watering trays. Consider which of these extras would be beneficial for your gardening needs.

Final Thoughts

Choosing the right seed starter tray is essential for successful seed germination and healthy plant growth. Consider the material, size, depth, drainage holes, dome or lid, price, and any extras when making your decision. With this buying guide in hand, I am confident you will find the best seed starter tray for your gardening needs. Happy planting!

Author Profile

Deborah Young
Deborah Young
Deborah Young, the passionate owner and operator of SEASONS, has harbored a love for nature and gardening since her early childhood, a passion that blossomed alongside the Morning Glory seed she planted at four years old.

Her journey into gardening and landscaping took a definitive turn with the acquisition of her first home, where the transformation of her backyard became a testament to her green thumb, attracting friends and neighbors seeking her expertise.

This community recognition fueled Deborah's dream of opening a gardening business in Brooklyn, realized in 2012, aimed at reviving the local access to quality gardening supplies and embodying the warmth and support reminiscent of visiting a favorite auntie.

Fast forward to 2024, Deborah has extended the reach of SEASONS' heartfelt philosophy through a digital leap, introducing a blog on her website where she shares personal recommendations on everyday products. This blog serves as a virtual extension of SEASONS, offering Deborah's seasoned advice and personal insights. Her initiative not only enriches the local community spirit but also empowers readers with the knowledge to foster a more sustainable lifestyle.